9 Comments
User's avatar
Kevin McGrane Sr.'s avatar

I’ve always been struck by how the “parish model” of church (it’s what I call it) seems to be universal and timeless. For hundreds of years, faith communities have gathered at a communal building or location for worship/learning/fellowship, no matter if it is a Christian chapel,a Jewish synagogue, a Muslim mosque, a Buddhist sangha: the community gathered at a place. Even druids gathered at common oak groves. That said, couldn’t ours today be a simple place, a minimalist place, something on the scale of a storefront or a Jehovah’s Witness Kingdom Hall? A single, self-contained facility? Yes, let’s also do house church, farm church, yurt church, pavilion at the park church, but let’s look at why parish church has lasted so long - “Why?”

Expand full comment
Fr. Cathie Caimano's avatar

I think you are conflating two different things.

gathering in a worship space is indeed almost as old as faith itself. As we know, building the temple was a huge achievement for the earliest Jews, which set the precedent for all of us who follow the faiths 'of the book'. Not to mention other faiths altogether.

On the other hand, having a worship space that is also a program space, classroom space, and office space (and all supported by one local congregation) is relatively new - its boom was in the 20th century.

And this is not sustainable. It's been killing organized religion - of all kinds - for decades.

sure, our worship space today *could* be many things. But it *must* be something different - and very soon - or we will lose the vast majority of them.

Expand full comment
Kevin McGrane Sr.'s avatar

Thank you for your response. I appreciate it. If you were able to create that “something different”, what would be your go-to scenario?

Expand full comment
Fr. Cathie Caimano's avatar

that is my whole ministry!

I think a new church is emerging, and we need to shepherd it into being.

Personally, i think we need to pay much more attention to the 'stuff' (as I say in this post) - we need to streamline our administration, organization, and finances, and excavate our worship and faith formation from the current 20th century institutional format it's in.

I think we need to embrace technology in the form of small business tools that help solopreneurs create their own enterprises and use them to create faith communities our ancient brothers and sisters would recognize and communities that today's seekers would want to join.

Expand full comment
Reinventing Christianity's avatar

Oooh, thanks for sharing a workable model for this. I’ve been thinking a lot lately about Urban Holmes’ assertion that worship needs a sacred time, sacred place and sacred person/shaman — ‘sacred’ as in set apart, to help the process of transcendence. House church is none of those things, but it’s definitely a sacred gathering.

Expand full comment
Fr. Cathie Caimano's avatar

and no matter what kind of gathering it is, it eventually needs some kind of management/structure around it, or it won't last.

Expand full comment
Reinventing Christianity's avatar

Some wisdom I’ve heard is that it works best with only one moving part: if you move from house to house, for instance, keep the same day/time and have the same administrative leader.

Expand full comment
Manny Faria's avatar

Good stuff. Thanks, Fr. Cathie. You hit on both sides of the issue and I've spent a lot of time thinking about it myself.

Expand full comment
Fr. Cathie Caimano's avatar

I'd love to hear more of what you're thinking!!

Expand full comment