Most churches are not asking pastors to do more—they are asking them to do the impossible.
The modern pastoral job description would require several full-time positions in any other organization.
William (Bill) Harrison is president of Lutheran Theological Seminary, Saskatoon, former chair of the Saskatoon Theological Union Common Faculty, and the author of Leadership in a Shrinking Church. While I’d recommend his book for pastors and church leaders more broadly, Harrison clearly names dynamics of pastoral leadership that are often assumed without being explicitly named.
Specifically, he describes how the demands of the pastoral role have continued to expand over time, even going back hundreds of years. He writes:
“We have accumulated, in the lives of most [pastors] the following priorities: eucharistic leadership, building construction and maintenance, preaching and teaching, therapeutic level pastoral care, trained management, and numbers oriented mission…
We have placed very high expectations on the shoulders of presbyters. At the same time, we commonly offer small salaries and an assumption of mobility that tests personal relationships and family ties. This would be tough even in a growing church.” (p. 82)
How we got here
Notice what Harrison points out. Pastoral leadership began as Eucharistic leadership—word and sacrament.
With the construction of church buildings, even beginning in the Middle Ages, came responsibility for construction and maintenance. More recently, the pastor is expected to function as a counselor, corporate executive, and—since the COVID-19 pandemic—a digital outreach specialist.
These are, in themselves, full-time roles in larger organizations.
Yet within a church setting, a pastor is often expected—sometimes unwittingly—to fulfill all of them.
This is not a failure of effort. It is a failure of structure.
Subscribe to Free Range Priest to get Substack Seminary posts in your email inbox.
Become a paid Free Range Priest subscriber to join us for livestream Conversations, replays, and the Chat.
Doing less with less
So what do we do instead?
Harrison suggests that “there are some things that can be done about this situation.” First, he argues, churches must clarify what church leadership is about today.
At minimum, this means being explicit about what a church expects from its pastor—and what can reasonably be completed within the scope of pay and time.
“The second,” Harrison says, “is to foster a team that can pick up necessary work that clergy need to drop in order to do their primary work.”
“The third,” and likely the most underrated, “is to let go of tasks that do not contribute sufficiently to the work that needs to be done” (p. 82).
Harrison summarizes this posture as doing less with less.
Why this matters for Substack Seminary
One of the recurring conversations in Substack Seminary is the decline of institutional Christianity. While there are many reasons to grieve this reality, there is also an opportunity embedded within it.
Decline creates permission to rewrite expectations.
Especially expectations around the role of the pastor or clergyperson.
This kind of work—naming misaligned expectations, reclaiming sustainable leadership, and reimagining ministry for a smaller, leaner church—is exactly what Substack Seminary exists to do.
Substack Seminary is not about doing church better by working harder. It’s about learning how to lead faithfully within real limits.
If you’re a pastor, church leader, or thoughtful practitioner navigating ministry with fewer resources and greater complexity, this is the conversation you belong in.
Join us.
Substack Seminary is a Newsletter that is part of
a Free Range Priest subscription.
During Quarters, you’ll get blogs thematic blogs:
Q1: Vision & Systematic Change
Q2: Structure & Business Model
Q3: Theology & Community
Q4: Technology & Collaboration
Paid FRP subscribers join Conversations live on Thursdays at 3:30 Eastern (during Quarters), and get the replay + chat invitation on Mondays.
You don’t have to do this alone. Subscribe to join the ‘home for weirdo pastors’.
At Free Range Priest, we’re bringing church to people.
Bite-sized ways that YOU can re-imagine ministry and get ‘unstuck’.
Right now. Today.
Subscribe to re-discover ministry JOY.